Top 5 Best Newsletter Platforms for You: Find the Perfect Fit
In today’s digital world, a strong newsletter is one of the most valuable tools a creator agency can use to build relationships, establish thought leadership, and drive engagement. In our previous blog post, we talked about going beyond social media and expanding your audience reach. But with so many platforms available, how do you know which one is the best fit for your needs?
Recently I found myself doing a deeper dive on the different newsletter platforms to find one that best suits my agency.
Whether you're looking to grow your audience, automate outreach, or create beautifully branded content, the right platform can make all the difference. Here’s a breakdown of the top newsletter platforms and which one might be the best choice for you.
1. Substack – Best for Thought Leadership & Monetization
If your agency wants to share in-depth industry insights and even monetize your content, Substack is a great option. It's a simple platform designed for long-form content, making it perfect for thought leadership and community-building.
✅ Pros:
Easy setup and management
Supports free & paid subscriptions
Strong SEO and organic discoverability
Simple, clean formatting for long-form content
🚫 Cons:
Limited design customization
More focused on writing than visuals
Best for: Agencies that want to establish authority, provide industry insights, and explore paid subscriptions.
2. ConvertKit – Best for Audience Growth & Automation
If you need advanced automation tools and detailed audience segmentation, ConvertKit is an excellent choice. It’s ideal for agencies looking to nurture leads and personalize email marketing campaigns.
✅ Pros:
Advanced automation & audience segmentation
Simple, clean email templates
Great for lead generation & nurturing relationships
Supports paid subscriptions
🚫 Cons:
Limited design customization compared to Mailchimp
Pricing can increase as your subscriber list grows
Best for: Agencies focusing on growing and nurturing an engaged email list through targeted content.
3. Mailchimp – Best for Customization & Brand Aesthetics
For agencies that want visually appealing emails with full customization, Mailchimp is a go-to. With drag-and-drop editing, analytics, and A/B testing, it’s perfect for brands that prioritize strong design and marketing insights.
✅ Pros:
Highly customizable email templates
Easy-to-use drag-and-drop editor
A/B testing & analytics for optimization
Integrates well with CRMs and other tools
🚫 Cons:
Pricing increases quickly with subscriber growth
Some automation features are limited compared to ConvertKit
Best for: Agencies that want visually appealing newsletters with a strong brand identity.
4. Flodesk – Best for Aesthetic & Brand-Focused Agencies
If your agency prioritizes design and branding, Flodesk is an excellent option. It offers stunning templates and a flat-rate pricing model, which means your costs don’t increase as your subscriber count grows.
✅ Pros:
Beautiful, modern email designs
Flat-rate pricing (great for scaling)
Simple, user-friendly interface
🚫 Cons:
Less advanced automation compared to ConvertKit or Mailchimp
Fewer third-party integrations
Best for: Agencies that want to prioritize aesthetics without worrying about fluctuating pricing.
5. Beehiiv – Best for Growth & Monetization
Beehiiv is built for newsletter growth, making it a top choice for agencies that want to expand their audience and monetize through ads, referrals, or paid subscriptions.
✅ Pros:
Designed specifically for newsletter growth
Includes referral & virality features
Allows monetization (ads, paid subscriptions, etc.)
More customization options than Substack
🚫 Cons:
Fewer integrations than Mailchimp or ConvertKit
Limited design templates
Best for: Agencies looking for rapid audience growth and monetization opportunities.
Which One Should You Choose?
For thought leadership & simplicity: Substack
For automation & segmentation: ConvertKit
For design-heavy newsletters: Mailchimp or Flodesk
For growth & monetization: Beehiiv
Regardless of which platform you choose, the key is to create consistent, engaging, and valuable content that resonates with your audience.
Was this help? Follow @itsjdsprojects for more creator growth tips!
